Ardennes 1944, by Antony Beevor

Reprinted from The Weekly Standard

The last German offensive of World War II began at 5:30 a.m. on December 16, 1944.  The rank-and-file German soldier thought he was giving Paris back to the Führer for a “Christmas present.”  The more experienced Wehrmacht commanders knew that, even should they reach the Meuse or—more fantastically—capture Antwerp, they were fighting but to delay Allied victory.

Caught off-guard much as Germans had been at Normandy, the Allies were the victims of a massive intelligence failure and a degree of holiday-season complacency.  They had failed to notice the buildup of 400 thousand enemy infantry, 1200 tanks, and over 4 thousand artillery pieces.  Many men and senior officers were on Christmas leave.

The 101st Airborne Division, the Screaming Eagles, to whom the pivotal defense of Bastogne was shortly to fall, were scheduled for leave in Paris and both their commanding officer and their deputy commander had already left.  Thus the 101st were led into their greatest fight by the division artillery commander, General Anthony C. McAuliffe.  When Bastogne was surrounded and the American field hospital captured, when our artillery was down to ten rounds per gun per day and one in four men had been wounded or killed, General McAuliffe had the honor of rejecting the German surrender demand with a single word: “Nuts.”  This colloquialism had to be explained to the Germans and has thrilled military historians, filmmakers, and fighting Americans ever since.

But not everything was nearly so inspiring, particularly in the early days of the offensive, which discovered serious flaws in the Allied command: Bradley was caught completely by surprise with his headquarters in the wrong place.  The stubborn and chronically unimaginative General Hodges, who had already ground down his First Army in the previous months’ fighting in the Hürtgen Forrest, was again unable to adapt to a changing situation.  But the worst offender was the famous British field marshal Montgomery, despised by every commander with whom he came into contact and whose personality was so corrosive that Antony Beevor speculates he might have suffered from “what today would be called high-functioning Asperger syndrome.”  Montgomery spent most of the offensive jockeying for overall command of the Allied ground forces—a task to which he was unsuited both militarily and politically.  Thanks to Montgomery, the American military victory in the Ardennes was also a British political defeat and the end of serious British influence in the conduct of the ground war.

Anthony Beevor’s book is a generally excellent balance between localized anecdotes and the more broadly historical account which they flavor.  The research is meticulous and the pacing is excellent.  In the event, the dramatic German defeat in the Ardennes crushed the German army to a degree that left it totally unprepared to fend off Russia’s Vistula-Oder offensive in January.  The German command had failed to consider the terrible road conditions which bogged down their tanks and were unaccountably stingy with fuel and strategic reserves.  But, principally, they had underestimated the speed with which Eisenhower would react, and the tenacity, skill and courage with which the American soldier would fight.

Research: 9/10

Storytelling: 8/10

Vitality: 8.5/10

Overall Goodness Rating (OGR): 8.8/10

Ardennes 1944: The Battle of the Bulge, by Antony Beevor.  Viking Press, 2015.  480 pages.

440 thoughts on “Ardennes 1944, by Antony Beevor

  1. Pingback: cialis cost
  2. Pingback: cialis 20 mg price
  3. Pingback: Viagra mail order
  4. Pingback: generic ventolin
  5. Pingback: tadalafil 10
  6. Pingback: naltrexone 50
  7. Pingback: cialis black
  8. Pingback: viagra samples
  9. Pingback: tylenol order
  10. Pingback: viagra substitute
  11. Pingback: cheap viagra
  12. Pingback: viagra 100mg
  13. Pingback: viagra generic
  14. Pingback: ed pills
  15. Pingback: erection pills
  16. Pingback: online pharmacy
  17. Pingback: vardenafil usa
  18. Pingback: levitra cost
  19. Pingback: buy cialis
  20. Pingback: viagra samples
  21. Pingback: real casino online
  22. Pingback: quick cash loans
  23. Pingback: payday advance
  24. Pingback: viagra 100mg
  25. Pingback: 5 mg cialis
  26. Pingback: online casino be
  27. Pingback: cialis 20
  28. Pingback: cialis to buy
  29. Pingback: viagra generic
  30. Pingback: viagra
  31. Pingback: buy viagra pills
  32. Pingback: viagra 100mg
  33. Pingback: when to buy viagra
  34. Pingback: cheap viagra
  35. Pingback: cialistodo.com
  36. Pingback: goodrx cialis
  37. Pingback: generic viagra
  38. Pingback: viagra alternative
  39. Pingback: online viagra
  40. Pingback: Cialis 80mg uk
  41. Pingback: viagra for sale
  42. Pingback: otc viagra
  43. Pingback: viagra prices
  44. Pingback: buy viagra online
  45. Pingback: viagra generic
  46. Pingback: cheap 25mg viagra
  47. Pingback: cheap viagra rush
  48. Pingback: cialis results
  49. Pingback: generic cialis
  50. Pingback: cialis tablets
  51. Pingback: tadalafil tablets
  52. Pingback: catapres purchase
  53. Pingback: cheap cipro 750mg
  54. Pingback: claritin uk
  55. Pingback: gambling casino
  56. Pingback: casino real money
  57. Pingback: casino world
  58. Pingback: viagra san diego
  59. Pingback: accc car insurance
  60. Pingback: generic cialis buy
  61. Pingback: payday loans tulsa
  62. Pingback: buy cialis canada
  63. Pingback: viagra 100 mg
  64. Pingback: cbd capsules
  65. Pingback: buy an essay
  66. Pingback: buy essay cheap
  67. Pingback: free paper writer
  68. Pingback: essays
  69. Pingback: cleocin 150mg otc
  70. Pingback: jual cialis kaskus
  71. Pingback: buy combivent
  72. Pingback: cialis online
  73. Pingback: coumadin australia
  74. Pingback: cozaar online
  75. Pingback: buy a dissertation
  76. Pingback: cymbalta otc
  77. Pingback: depakote coupon
  78. Pingback: diamox generic
  79. Pingback: buy cialis
  80. Pingback: cheapest imdur
  81. Pingback: cialis 20mg price
  82. Pingback: tadalafil cheap
  83. Pingback: tadalafil for sale
  84. Pingback: imodium price
  85. Pingback: this
  86. Pingback: imuran pharmacy
  87. Pingback: lopressor uk
  88. Pingback: meclizine otc
  89. Pingback: mobic 15mg cost
  90. Pingback: motrin usa
  91. Pingback: periactin tablets
  92. Pingback: phenergan prices
  93. Pingback: order procardia
  94. Pingback: proscar 5 mg nz
  95. Pingback: viagra in calgary
  96. Pingback: provigil prices
  97. Pingback: pulmicort cost
  98. Pingback: pyridium australia
  99. Pingback: buy reglan 10mg
  100. Pingback: cheap revatio
  101. Pingback: risperdal price
  102. Pingback: how to buy rogaine
  103. Pingback: cheapest seroquel
  104. Pingback: spiriva otc
  105. Pingback: toprol purchase
  106. Pingback: tricor tablets
  107. Pingback: vantin coupon
  108. Pingback: cheap zanaflex
  109. Pingback: Look At This
  110. Pingback: cheapest zocor
  111. Pingback: escitalopram otc
  112. Pingback: pioglitazone usa
  113. Pingback: cheapest meclizine
  114. Pingback: buy atomoxetine
  115. Pingback: irbesartan prices
  116. Pingback: chewable cialis
  117. Pingback: cost of cephalexin
  118. Pingback: viagra prank
  119. Pingback: cheapest clozapine
  120. Pingback: 36 hour cialis
  121. Pingback: warfarin 5mg price
  122. Pingback: desmopressin usa
  123. Pingback: cialis asia
  124. Pingback: fluconazole coupon
  125. Pingback: phenytoin tablets
  126. Pingback: buy cialis doctor
  127. Pingback: bisacodyl 5mg otc
  128. Pingback: uk buy viagra
  129. Pingback: venlafaxine pills
  130. Pingback: permethrin canada
  131. Pingback: 141genericExare
  132. Pingback: jgustmqv
  133. Pingback: bptjkejc
  134. Pingback: glipizide coupon
  135. Pingback: buy cialis
  136. Pingback: viagra 100mg price
  137. Pingback: azathioprine price
  138. Pingback: stromectol ireland
  139. Pingback: combivent coupon
  140. Pingback: metoprolol online
  141. Pingback: prednisolone rash
  142. Pingback: prednisolone 2 mg
  143. Pingback: ovulation clomid
  144. Pingback: dapoxetine forum
  145. Pingback: priligy en mexico
  146. Pingback: synthroid tsh
  147. Pingback: buy thesis online
  148. Pingback: propecia 5
  149. Pingback: generic cialis
  150. Pingback: metformin function
  151. Pingback: metformin purpose
  152. Pingback: rx online

Comment